Will Rogers Newsletter
Sign-up to receive daily news on Will Rogers by email.
Will Rogers Filmography
Source:
Theiapolis
Will Rogers Resources
Table of Content
Latest Film News
Latest news on Will Rogers
IssuesOn FNS, Wallace did not challenge Kyl on false claim that Republican economist Feldstein opposes an economic stimulus package
On the November 16 edition of Fox News Sunday, host Chris Wallace did not challenge the
false assertion by Sen. Jon Kyl (R-AZ) that Republican economist "Marty
Feldstein says we shouldn't" enact a new economic stimulus plan.
But Feldstein wrote in an October 30 op-ed in The
Washington Post that "[t]he
only way to prevent a deepening recession will be a temporary program of
increased government spending."
During a discussion about the economic crisis, Sen. Byron
Dorgan (D-ND) asserted that "we can't proceed without some sort of
a significant stimulus plan" and that "Marty Feldstein, top
Republican economist, says we should." Kyl replied: "Marty
Feldstein says we shouldn't. As a matter of fact, he testified before the
Finance Committee in favor of the last stimulus package. He's now written
that, of course, it didn't work. They never do."
However, while Feldstein, a former adviser for Sen. John
McCain's presidential campaign, wrote in an August 6 Wall Street Journal op-ed that "the tax rebate was
a flop," and "one-time tax rebates are not a cost-effective way to
increase economic activity," Wallace did not point out that in his
October 30 op-ed, titled
"The Stimulus Plan We Need Now," Feldstein wrote:
The only way to prevent a deepening recession will be
a temporary program of increased government spending. Previous attempts to use
government spending to stimulate an economic recovery, particularly spending on
infrastructure, have not been successful because of long legislative lags that
delayed the spending until a recovery was well underway. But while past
recessions lasted an average of only about 12 months, this downturn is likely
to last much longer, providing the scope for successful countercyclical
spending.
A fiscal package of $100 billion is
not likely to be large enough to revive the economy. The fall in household
wealth resulting from the collapse of the stock market and the decline of home
prices may cut aggregate spending by $300 billion a year or more.
The president-elect should focus on
developing a mechanism for identifying and funding spending initiatives that
can occur quickly and that would otherwise not be done. While it would be good
if some of the increased spending also contributed to long-term productivity,
the key is to stimulate demand. Any plan to finance this spending by raising
taxes, even if postponed, as Sen. Barack Obama has suggested, would hurt the
recovery by causing affected taxpayers to cut their spending now.
The increased government spending
should include not only money for infrastructure such as bridges and roads but
also for a wide range of equipment. Rebuilding some of the military capacity
that has been depleted by the wars in Iraq
and Afghanistan
could be done relatively quickly and should be part of the overall package.
Although the economy is facing
severe challenges, the president-elect can turn the situation around by
introducing legislation to deal with the downward spiral in home prices and
with the declining level of aggregate demand. It is important that such
legislation be enacted as quickly as possible.
From the November 16 edition of Fox News Sunday:
WALLACE: Senator Dorgan, there does
seem to be a sense on Capitol Hill that, at least in this lame duck session,
all you're gonna be able to pass is a much smaller plan, perhaps $6
billion dollars for expanded unemployment benefits. Is that how you read it?
DORGAN: It appears that might be the
case. I mean, we're gonna try to do more. But, you know, we've been
through this. Will Rogers
said back in the 1930s, he said, "The unemployed around here haven't been
eating regularly, but we'll get to them as soon as everybody else gets fixed
up." The question is: What do you do about the unemployed? What do you do
about the people about to lose their jobs? The number that I used earlier -- 3
to 5 million jobs at risk as a result of the auto sector -- that's not my
number. That's the Chamber of Commerce number, which very strongly supports
that something should be done.
But, you know, my point is this.
There is a time when you have to make significant investments, and those
investments would produce assets. Building roads, building bridges, building
schools, libraries -- repairing all those things. All of that puts people to
work immediately. Now, last month there was an apoplectic seizure over the
notion that consumer spending was down. Well, you know what? Consumer spending
is not gonna go up if people are out of work. You've gotta put people
back on the payroll. That's when you get consumer spending that begins to
drive the economy again. So, I don't -- we can't proceed without
some sort of a significant stimulus plan, and when you finish that spending you
ought to have an asset to show for it. Marty Feldstein, top Republican
economist, says we should -- the Chamber of Commerce. I mean, this is not a
Democratic plan. Most people believe that we ought to do something to put
people back to work.
WALLACE: All right. OK.
KYL: Marty Feldstein says we
shouldn't. As a matter of fact, he testified before the Finance Committee
in favor of the last stimulus package. He's now written that, of course,
it didn't work. They never do.
WALLACE: All right, gentlemen. I --
we can - we can debate this. And you will debate it on the floor of the
Senate. I want to move to some other business.
Published: Sun, 16 Nov 2008 23:14:07 GMT - Source: Mediamatters.Org - Read the article
Sign-up to receive daily news on Will Rogers by email.